Menu Home

Here’s what goes on in my head pretty much every time I encounter Tanzanian prosperity theology

We are really looking forward to getting back to church in Dar es Salaam, and once again listening to Tanzanian Christian teaching regularly.

Here is a recent Facebook post from our church, with the summary of Pastor Dondo’s sermon from Sunday.

My first instinct on reading this is to think, “That is wrong! This is an over-realised eschatology, pushing into the ‘now’ the kind of shalom of the ‘not yet’. Where is the place for suffering in the Christian life? Where is the place for a life modelled on a crucified Saviour? …”

Then I take a breath, I try to delay my judgements and think flexibly. I look again and here is what I notice:

1. The list of “spiritually, intellectually and physically” is a way of speaking of people in a holistic sense. I am much more likely to make distinctions here, something like, ‘God wants us to be spiritually healthy, but this is not relevant to physical health.’ I separate out the person. Tanzanians don’t do this, so it’s a nonsense to talk about prospering spiritually without physical prosperity. But the other way around is true also: physical prosperity is bankrupt without spiritual ardour and discipline. My separation comes from passages in the New Testament that point us beyond suffering now, or suggest that suffering now has a good spiritual purpose, but I wonder how I might read those passages if I wasn’t already used to separating one part of the self from another.

2. There is good biblical reason to believe that God wants good things for his children. After all, Jesus himself asked, “Which of you, if your son asks for bread will give him a stone? Or if he asks for a fish would give him a snake? If you then, though you are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father in Heaven give good gifts to those who ask him?” (Matt 7:9-11)

3. God is Patron in this understanding. We in the west have a hard time getting our heads around patronage cultures, but perhaps the ambassador language is useful. If an important person sends you their messenger and that person is in rags or poor health, what does it tell you about their employer? That they don’t look after their employees! They are not to be trusted. If God does not provide for his own people, what does that say about him? Why should people listen to them, and hear God’s message? It’s so interesting to me that prosperity in this little Facebook post is put in the context of mission.

This post on Facebook is in English, but perhaps you can get a sense of the non-western thinking going on in it!

Categories: Grassroots theology Tanzania Written by Tamie

Tagged as:

Tamie Davis

Tamie Davis is an Aussie living in Tanzania, writing at meetjesusatuni.com.

4 replies

  1. Tamie et la famille, welcome back to Tz. Interesting to read your blog. First your separation of West/South or non western is problematic. As an elite Tanzanian that travel and can speak western language, and access lots of western ideas from media etc, sometimes i feel more connected to the west world than to my rural remote village in Moshi.

    Recently i visited Accra Ghana and just saw how vast, big urban based Christian churches are n operate. Prosperity gospel in Africa, including urban Tz is a big thing, these days.

    One of the things i deeply love and appreciate TAFES ministry is the fact that we see youths who are willing to volunteer, willing to go for less even when they are saving Jesus. I wonder whether AFES has similar experience?

    While its ok for church to preach about prosperity, the means to get many people out of poverty wont be through prayers and fasting but rather through production of goods and services in a very dynamic and competitive world, through innovation, through resilience! Its possibly a right time now that churches put more resources in training and educating its youth?

    Lets chat more when u are back…

    1. Hi Zabdiel! Greetings to you and Neema and the children!

      I love what you say about the separation between western and non-western. We have spent much of our time in Australia trying to explain to Aussies how urban life is in many parts of Tanzania. People are often surprised to discover that Dar Es Salaam is the size of Sydney!

      Our experience in AFES was very much one of being trained in the spiritual things of this world and called to give up our lives for Christ – so what you say about TAFES definitely resonates. However, our formation gave very little attention to Christian work and productivity – either teaching about prosperity, or the practicalities and economics. I think that’s pretty par for the course in Australian Christianity.

      We will see you soon!

  2. Hi Tamie,

    That’s super interesting! Is your church in TZ run in English and Swahili?

    We pray everything goes well with moving back to TZ. Will be in touch with you guys once you’re settled again.

    Blessings

    Marcus

    >

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: